The tip jar disappears from a busy café, and three customers each have a story. Exactly one of them is lying, and their statements give the answer away.
- Mia: "Raj took it."
- Raj: "I didn't!"
- Tess: "Mia's telling the truth."
- Exactly one of them is lying.
Who stole the tip jar? One of them is lying.
Think it through first. When you're ready:
Raj
If Mia were lying, Raj would be innocent and Tess would be wrong to back Mia, so two people (Mia and Tess) would be lying, which breaks the one-liar rule. So Mia is telling the truth, Raj took the jar, and his denial is the lie.