A golden egg vanishes from a museum during a snowstorm. Three guards each give an alibi, and one of the stories does not fit the snowy scene.
- Guard 1: "I never left the front desk." He is holding a torch there.
- Guard 2: "I was in the staff room, making tea." He is holding a steaming mug.
- Guard 3: "I was outside checking the doors. I ran in just now!"
- The only way in is the glass door, and the snow outside it is smooth with no footprints.
One guard is lying. Who took the golden egg?
Think it through first. When you're ready:
Guard 3 is the one lying
Guard 3 says he was outside and has just run in, but his boots and shoulders are completely dry and there is no snow on his cap. The snow drift against the only door has no footprints, so nobody has opened it. He could not have been outside, which makes Guard 3 the liar.