A gold cup is stolen from the Rainy Town museum during a storm. Three suspects give their alibis, and one small detail gives away the liar.
- Mia: "I was asleep upstairs all night."
- Tom: "I just walked here from the bus stop."
- Ben: "I've been out walking my dog for an hour."
- Tom and Ben both arrive with dripping umbrellas and wet coats, and puddles form under them.
Who stole the gold cup?
Think it through first. When you're ready:
Ben
Ben says he has been walking his dog for an hour in the storm, but his dog is perfectly dry and fluffy with no puddle beneath it. A dog that had really been out in the rain for an hour would be soaked. Ben's story is false, so he is the liar, and the thief.