A bicycle goes missing from the school yard. Five students each make a claim, and exactly two of them are lying.
- Ana: "Dee is lying."
- Ben: "Ana is telling the truth."
- Cy: "Eli took the bicycle."
- Dee: "I did not take the bicycle."
- Eli: "Cy is lying."
- Exactly two of the five are lying.
Who took the bicycle?
Think it through first. When you're ready:
Dee
Assume Dee took the bicycle. Then Dee's denial is false, so Dee is a liar. Ana's claim that Dee is lying is true, so Ana is truthful. Cy accuses Eli, which is false, so Cy is a liar. Eli says Cy is lying, which is true, so Eli is truthful, and Ben's claim that Ana is truthful is also true. That gives exactly two liars, Cy and Dee. Checking the other four possible culprits gives a different number of liars.