A freshly painted fence has a smudge on the gate. Three neighbours each make a claim, and only one of them is lying.
- Ruth: "Sam painted the fence."
- Sam: "Tom painted the fence."
- Tom: "I did not paint the fence."
- Exactly one of the three is lying.
Who painted the fence?
Think it through first. When you're ready:
Sam
If Ruth painted it, Ruth is lying and Sam is lying too, which is two liars. If Tom painted it, Ruth and Tom are lying and Sam is telling the truth, which is two liars again. If Sam painted it, Ruth is telling the truth, Sam is lying (Tom did not paint it), and Tom's denial is true. Exactly one liar, so Sam painted the fence.