🧠 Riddle #70 of 232
Three islanders stand before you; each is a knight (always truthful) or a knave (always lies). The first, Ash, says: 'Bay and Cy are the same type as each other.' You then ask Cy: 'Are Ash and Bay the same type?' What does Cy answer — yes or no?
Think about it first. When you're ready:
Yes
Every arrangement consistent with Ash's claim gives Cy the answer 'yes', whether Cy is telling the truth or lying.