🕵️ Riddle #61 of 230
A small bronze frog was taken from a gallery at about 4:30 p.m. Guy says, "I was on the 4:10 train by then. The ride takes fifty minutes, the walk home from the station takes twenty, and I walked through my door as the clock struck five." What is wrong with Guy's story?
Think about it first. When you're ready:
His timeline is impossible (home at 5:20)
4:10 plus a 50-minute train and a 20-minute walk is 5:20, so he could not have been home at five.